S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K
________________________________________________________________________
8320
2011-2012 Regular Sessions
I N A S S E M B L Y
June 13, 2011
___________
Introduced by M. of A. CUSICK -- (at request of the Department of Law)
-- read once and referred to the Committee on Health
AN ACT to amend the public health law, in relation to creating an
on-line real time controlled substance reporting system to monitor the
prescribing and dispensing of certain controlled substances
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "Internet
System for Tracking Over-Prescribing (I-STOP) Act".
S 2. The public health law is amended by adding a new section 3343-a
to read as follows:
S 3343-A. ON-LINE REAL-TIME CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM. 1.
ESTABLISHMENT OF SYSTEM. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION, ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN A SYSTEM FOR COLLECT-
ING, MONITORING AND REPORTING DATA CONCERNING THE PRESCRIBING AND
DISPENSING OF SCHEDULE II, III, IV, OR V CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES, OR ANY
OTHER SUBSTANCES SPECIFIED BY THE COMMISSIONER, THAT ARE PRESCRIBED OR
DISPENSED. SUCH SYSTEM SHALL ALLOW PRACTITIONERS AND PHARMACISTS TO
MONITOR AND REPORT SUCH DATA BY MEANS OF AN INTERNET PORTAL AND A
WEBSITE AND ANY OTHER ELECTRONIC MEANS DEEMED APPROPRIATE BY THE COMMIS-
SIONER. SUCH SYSTEM SHALL ENABLE PRACTITIONERS AND PHARMACISTS TO MONI-
TOR AND REPORT SUCH DATA AT THE TIME A PRESCRIPTION IS ISSUED OR SUCH
SUBSTANCE IS DISPENSED. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL ADOPT AND SUCH SYSTEM
SHALL MAINTAIN PROCEDURES AND SAFEGUARDS TO ENSURE THE PRIVACY AND
CONFIDENTIALITY OF PATIENT INFORMATION AND TO ENSURE THAT ANY DATA
COLLECTED OR REPORTED IS NOT UNLAWFULLY ACCESSED OR DISCLOSED. THE
COMMISSIONER SHALL ALSO ESTABLISH ACCEPTABLE ERROR TOLERANCE RATES FOR
DATA AND PROCEDURES FOR PRACTITIONERS AND PHARMACISTS TO FOLLOW IN THE
EVENT OF A TECHNOLOGICAL FAILURE.
2. REPORTING OBLIGATIONS. EVERY PRACTITIONER OR PHARMACIST WITHIN THE
STATE OR ANY OTHER DISPENSER WHO HAS OBTAINED A LICENSE, PERMIT OR OTHER
EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD11782-01-1
A. 8320 2
AUTHORIZATION TO OPERATE FROM THE COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION, OR ANY
AGENT THEREOF, SHALL REPORT TO THE COMMISSIONER THE DATA SPECIFIED IN
PARAGRAPH A OR B OF THIS SUBDIVISION THROUGH AN INTERNET PORTAL AND
WEBSITE MAINTAINED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND ANY OTHER METHOD DEEMED
APPROPRIATE BY THE COMMISSIONER, UPON ISSUING A PRESCRIPTION OR DISPENS-
ING A SCHEDULE II, III, IV, OR V CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE OR ANY OTHER
SUBSTANCE SPECIFIED BY THE COMMISSIONER; PROVIDED THAT SUCH REPORTING
SHALL NOT BE REQUIRED FOR ANY SUCH SUBSTANCE ADMINISTERED DIRECTLY TO A
PATIENT, OR FOR SUCH SUBSTANCE DISPENSED PURSUANT TO SECTION THREE THOU-
SAND THREE HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR, THREE THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED THIRTY-SEV-
EN OR THREE THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED FORTY-TWO OF THIS CHAPTER OR ANY RULE
OR REGULATION PROMULGATED UNDER THOSE SECTIONS.
A. DATA TO BE REPORTED BY PRACTITIONERS. DATA CONCERNING SCHEDULE II,
III, IV, OR V CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES OR ANY OTHER SUBSTANCES SPECIFIED BY
THE COMMISSIONER THAT ARE PRESCRIBED SHALL INCLUDE BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO
THE FOLLOWING: PRACTITIONER PRESCRIPTION NUMBER; PRACTITIONER NATIONAL
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER; PATIENT NAME; PATIENT ADDRESS, INCLUDING STREET,
CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE; PATIENT DATE OF BIRTH; PATIENT'S SEX; DATE
PRESCRIPTION ISSUED; METRIC QUANTITY; NATIONAL DRUG CODE NUMBER OF THE
DRUG; NUMBER OF DAYS SUPPLY; PRACTITIONER DRUG ENFORCEMENT ADMINIS-
TRATION NUMBER; DATE PRESCRIPTION WRITTEN; SERIAL NUMBER OF OFFICIAL
PRESCRIPTION FORM, OR AN IDENTIFIER DESIGNATED BY THE DEPARTMENT;
PAYMENT METHOD, AND NUMBER OF REFILLS AUTHORIZED.
B. DATA TO BE REPORTED BY PHARMACISTS. DATA CONCERNING SCHEDULE II,
III, IV, OR V CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES OR ANY OTHER SUBSTANCES SPECIFIED BY
THE COMMISSIONER THAT ARE DISPENSED SHALL INCLUDE BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO
THE FOLLOWING: PHARMACY PRESCRIPTION NUMBER; PHARMACY'S NATIONAL IDEN-
TIFICATION NUMBER; PATIENT NAME; PATIENT ADDRESS, INCLUDING STREET,
CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE; PATIENT DATE OF BIRTH; PATIENT'S SEX; DATE
PRESCRIPTION FILLED; METRIC QUANTITY; NATIONAL DRUG CODE NUMBER OF THE
DRUG; NUMBER OF DAYS SUPPLY; PRACTITIONER DRUG ENFORCEMENT ADMINIS-
TRATION NUMBER; DATE PRESCRIPTION WRITTEN; SERIAL NUMBER OF OFFICIAL
PRESCRIPTION FORM, OR AN IDENTIFIER DESIGNATED BY THE COMMISSIONER;
PAYMENT METHOD; NUMBER OF REFILLS AUTHORIZED; AND REFILL NUMBER.
3. DUTY TO CONSULT DATABASE; PROHIBITIONS. EVERY PRACTITIONER OR
PHARMACIST WITHIN THE STATE, INCLUDING ANY OTHER DISPENSER WHO HAS
OBTAINED A LICENSE, PERMIT, OR OTHER AUTHORIZATION TO OPERATE FROM THE
COMMISSIONER OF EDUCATION, SHALL MAKE INQUIRY TO THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM ESTABLISHED PURSUANT TO SUBDIVISION ONE OF
THIS SECTION PRIOR TO PRESCRIBING OR DISPENSING ANY SCHEDULE II, III,
IV, OR V CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE OR ANY OTHER SUBSTANCE SPECIFIED BY THE
COMMISSIONER; PROVIDED THAT THIS SUBDIVISION AND PARAGRAPHS (A) AND (B)
HEREOF, SHALL NOT APPLY TO ANY SUCH SUBSTANCE ADMINISTERED DIRECTLY TO A
PATIENT OR FOR ANY SUCH SUBSTANCE DISPENSED PURSUANT TO SECTIONS THREE
THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR, THREE THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED THIR-
TY-SEVEN OR THREE THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED FORTY-TWO OF THIS CHAPTER AND
ANY RULE PROMULGATED THEREUNDER.
A. NO PRACTITIONER SHALL PRESCRIBE ANY SCHEDULE II, III, IV, OR V
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE OR ANY OTHER SUBSTANCE SPECIFIED BY THE COMMISSION-
ER WITHOUT REVIEWING A PATIENT'S CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE PRESCRIPTION
HISTORY AS SET FORTH IN THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING
SYSTEM TO DETERMINE THAT SUCH PRESCRIPTION IS MEDICALLY NECESSARY AND
WOULD NOT OTHERWISE VIOLATE SECTION THREE THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED FIFTY
OF THIS ARTICLE, OR, FOR PRESCRIPTIONS ELIGIBLE FOR REIMBURSEMENT BY THE
MEDICAID PROGRAM, SECTION ONE HUNDRED FORTY-FIVE-B OF THE SOCIAL
SERVICES LAW.
A. 8320 3
B. NO PHARMACIST SHALL DISPENSE ANY SCHEDULE II, III, IV, OR V
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE OR ANY OTHER SUBSTANCE SPECIFIED BY THE COMMISSION-
ER WITHOUT CONFIRMING THE EXISTENCE OF A MATCHING REPORT PROVIDED BY A
PRACTITIONER THROUGH THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM.
4. LIMITATIONS ON USE; DISCLOSURE RESTRICTIONS. A. NO PRACTITIONER OR
PHARMACIST SHALL DISCLOSE OR BE REQUIRED TO DISCLOSE ANY DATA VIEWED OR
RECEIVED THROUGH THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM
UNLESS SO REQUIRED BY A PROVISION OF LAW SPECIFICALLY RELATING TO THE
TREATMENT OF A PATIENT OR RELATING TO THE MANDATORY REPORTING OF AN
ILLEGAL USE OR ABUSE OF A CONTROLLED SCHEDULE II, III, IV OR V SUBSTANCE
OR ANY OTHER SUBSTANCE SPECIFIED BY THE COMMISSIONER. DISCLOSURE BY A
PRACTITIONER OR PHARMACIST TO ANY OTHER PERSON OR ENTITY, INCLUDING
DISCLOSURE IN THE CONTEXT OF A CIVIL ACTION WHERE THE DISCLOSURE IS
SOUGHT EITHER FOR THE PURPOSE OF DISCOVERY OR FOR EVIDENCE, IS PROHIBIT-
ED.
B. THE COMMISSIONER MAY NOT DISCLOSE DATA COLLECTED FOR THE ON-LINE
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM UNLESS SPECIFICALLY SO AUTHORIZED
BY LAW.
C. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL BE AUTHORIZED TO REVIEW BY ELECTRONIC MEANS
OR OTHERWISE THE DATE COLLECTED OR PUBLISHED FOR THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL BE AUTHORIZED TO
DISCLOSE DATA COLLECTED FOR OR PUBLISHED ON THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM, WITHOUT NECESSITY OF SUBPOENA, TO: (I) THE
DIRECTOR OF THE OFFICE OF THE PROFESSIONS OF THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
OR HIS OR HER DESIGNEE WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE LICENSURE, REGULATION,
OR DISCIPLINE OF PRACTITIONERS OR PHARMACISTS; (II) THE DEPUTY ATTORNEY
GENERAL FOR MEDICAID FRAUD CONTROL OR HIS OR HER DESIGNEE; (III) THE
MEDICAID INSPECTOR GENERAL OR HIS OR HER DESIGNEE; (IV) A JUDGE OR A
PROBATION OR PAROLE OFFICER ADMINISTERING A DIVERSION OR PROBATION
PROGRAM OF A CRIMINAL DEFENDANT WHO IS ELIGIBLE TO PARTICIPATE IN A
COURT-ORDERED DRUG DIVERSION OR PROBATION PROGRAM; OR (V) A PRACTITIONER
OR PHARMACIST, OR THEIR AGENT, WHO REQUESTS INFORMATION AND CERTIFIES
THAT THE REQUESTED INFORMATION IS FOR THE PURPOSE OF PROVIDING MEDICAL
OR PHARMACEUTICAL TREATMENT TO A CURRENT PATIENT. ANY PERSON TO WHOM THE
COMMISSIONER DISCLOSES SUCH DATA PURSUANT TO THIS PARAGRAPH SHALL NOT
PROVIDE SUCH DATA TO ANY OTHER PERSON OR ENTITY EXCEPT BY COURT ORDER,
WHICH SHALL BE GRANTED ONLY UPON APPLICATION BY SUCH PERSON AND ONLY
UPON A SHOWING THAT SUCH AN ORDER IS NECESSARY FOR SUCH PERSON TO CARRY
OUT HIS OR HER DUTIES AS A PUBLIC OFFICER OR AS A PRACTITIONER OR PHAR-
MACIST; PROVIDED THAT THE COMMISSIONER OF THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
MAY SUBMIT THE DATA AS EVIDENCE IN ANY ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING AS AUTHOR-
IZED BY LAW.
D. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL BE AUTHORIZED TO PROVIDE THE DATA REPORTED
TO OR COLLECTED FOR THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM
UPON RECEIPT OF A SUBPOENA ISSUED TO A POLICE OFFICER, DISTRICT ATTOR-
NEY, OR GRAND JURY, OR ANY FEDERAL OR STATE LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY.
E. THE COMMISSIONER MAY USE ANY DATA OR REPORTS COLLECTED FOR OR
REPORTED TO THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM FOR THE
PURPOSE OF IDENTIFYING MEDICAID RECIPIENTS WHOSE USAGE OF CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCES MAY BE APPROPRIATELY MANAGED BY A SINGLE OUTPATIENT PHARMACY
OR PRIMARY CARE PRACTITIONER.
F. NOTHING IN THIS SUBDIVISION SHALL BE INTERPRETED TO ALLOW A DISCLO-
SURE OF INFORMATION OTHERWISE PROHIBITED BY FEDERAL LAW.
5. IMMUNITY. NO PUBLIC OFFICER ACTING IN GOOD FAITH NOR THE STATE OF
NEW YORK NOR ANY DEPARTMENT, BUREAU, BOARD OR POLITICAL SUBDIVISION
THEREOF SHALL BE SUBJECT TO CIVIL LIABILITY ARISING FROM ANY FALSE
A. 8320 4
INFORMATION OF ANY DATA SUBMITTED TO OR REPORTED BY THE ON-LINE
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM; OR ANY FAILURE OF THE SYSTEM TO
ACCURATELY OR TIMELY REPORT SUCH DATA; OR FOR DISCLOSURE OF ANY DATA
MAINTAINED BY THE SYSTEM RESULTING FROM SUCH OFFICER ACTING IN GOOD
FAITH IN THE DISCHARGE OF HIS OR HER DUTIES.
6. CIVIL PENALTIES. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY OTHER PROVISION OF THIS ARTI-
CLE RELATING TO VIOLATIONS OF THIS ARTICLE:
A. ANY PRACTITIONER OR PHARMACIST WHO KNOWINGLY FAILS TO TRANSMIT DATA
TO THE COMMISSIONER AS REQUIRED BY SUBDIVISION TWO OF THIS SECTION SHALL
BE LIABLE TO THE STATE FOR A CIVIL PENALTY OF FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS FOR
THE FIRST PRESCRIPTION ISSUED WHICH IS NOT PROPERLY REPORTED; ONE THOU-
SAND DOLLARS FOR THE SECOND PRESCRIPTION NOT PROPERLY REPORTED; AND FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR EACH PRESCRIPTION NOT PROPERLY REPORTED THEREAFTER.
B. ANY PRACTITIONER OR PHARMACIST WHO KNOWINGLY FAILS TO REVIEW DATA
PRIOR TO PRESCRIBING OR DISPENSING ANY SUBSTANCE IN VIOLATION OF SUBDI-
VISION THREE OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE LIABLE TO THE STATE FOR A CIVIL
PENALTY OF FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS FOR THE FIRST PRESCRIPTION SO ISSUED;
ONE THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR THE SECOND PRESCRIPTION SO ISSUED; AND FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR EACH PRESCRIPTION ISSUED IN VIOLATION OF SUBDIVI-
SION THREE OF THIS SECTION THEREAFTER.
C. ANY PRACTITIONER OR PHARMACIST WHO KNOWINGLY DISCLOSES INFORMATION
IN VIOLATION OF SUBDIVISION FOUR OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE LIABLE FOR A
PENALTY OF NOT MORE THAN FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS FOR THE FIRST SUCH DISCLO-
SURE; ONE THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR THE SECOND SUCH DISCLOSURE; AND FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR EACH SUCH DISCLOSURE ISSUED IN VIOLATION OF SUBDI-
VISION THREE THEREAFTER.
D. NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL BE INTERPRETED TO PREEMPT OR RESTRICT
ANY CIVIL ACTION BY ANY INDIVIDUAL FOR DAMAGES RESULTING FROM AN ILLEGAL
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION IN VIOLATION OF SUBDIVISION FOUR OF THIS
SECTION, OR ANY OTHER CIVIL OR CRIMINAL ACTION BY THE COMMISSIONER OR
ANY LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY.
7. EDUCATION AND OUTREACH. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL WORK WITH THE STATE
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT AND ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL OR PRIVATE PROFESSIONAL
ORGANIZATION RESPONSIBLE FOR THE LICENSURE, REGULATION, OR DISCIPLINE OF
PRACTITIONERS, PHARMACISTS, AND OTHER PERSONS WHO ARE AUTHORIZED TO
PRESCRIBE, ADMINISTER, OR DISPENSE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES, FOR THE DEVEL-
OPMENT OF A CONTINUING EDUCATION PROGRAM ABOUT THE PURPOSES AND USES OF
THE ON-LINE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE REPORTING SYSTEM ESTABLISHED BY THIS
SECTION. THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SHALL WORK WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SERVICES FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF A CONTINUING EDUCATION PROGRAM
FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS ABOUT THE PURPOSES AND USES OF THE ELEC-
TRONIC SYSTEM FOR MONITORING ESTABLISHED IN THIS SECTION.
8. RULES AND REGULATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER SHALL PROMULGATE RULES AND
REGULATIONS NECESSARY TO EFFECTUATE THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION;
PROVIDED HOWEVER, THE COMMISSIONER SHALL NOT PROMULGATE ANY RULE OR
REGULATION THAT REQUIRES ANY PRACTITIONER OR PHARMACIST TO PAY A FEE OR
TAX SPECIFICALLY DEDICATED TO THE OPERATION OF THE SYSTEM.
S 3. This act shall take effect immediately; provided, however, that
subdivisions 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 of section 3343-a of the public health
law as added by section two of this act shall take effect one year after
such effective date.