Relates to clarifying the number of signatures required on an independent nominating petition in a municipality with less than a thousand residents; relates to declination of office and filling vacancies; relates to establishing residency at the time of nomination in village elections; relates to paper ballots counted by hand in village elections and eliminating the ability of a candidate to timely file via mailing with postmark before midnight of the last date to file a petition.
Ayes (58): Addabbo, Avella, Ball, Bonacic, Boyle, Breslin, Carlucci, DeFrancisco, Diaz, Dilan, Farley, Felder, Flanagan, Gallivan, Gianaris, Gipson, Golden, Griffo, Grisanti, Hannon, Hassell-Thomps, Hoylman, Kennedy, Klein, Krueger, Lanza, Larkin, LaValle, Libous, Little, Marcellino, Marchione, Martins, Maziarz, Montgomery, Nozzolio, O'Brien, O'Mara, Parker, Peralta, Perkins, Ranzenhofer, Ritchie, Rivera, Robach, Sampson, Sanders, Savino, Serrano, Seward, Skelos, Squadron, Stavisky, Stewart-Cousins, Tkaczyk, Valesky, Young, Zeldin
Excused (3): Espaillat, Latimer, Smith
TITLE OF BILL: An act to amend the election law, in relation to clarifying the number of signatures required on an independent nominating petition in a municipality with less than a thousand residents, declination of office and filling vacancies, establishing residency at the time of nomination in village elections, paper ballots counted by hand in village elections and eliminating the ability of a candidate to timely file via mailing with postmark before midnight of the last date to file a petition
To update several provisions of the Election Law to address certain issues affecting village elections.
SUMMARY OF PROVISIONS:
Section one amends § 15-108(6) of the Election Law to clarify that the actual number of required signatures for an independent nominating petition in a village with less than a thousand residents is 5% of registered voters at the previous village election.
Section two adds a new subdivision to § 15-128 of the Election Law, Notice to Person Chosen to a Village Office, to provide a procedure in the event that a candidate elected for office declines the position. This new language clarifies that a vacancy in office is created when someone declines office, which should subsequently be filled subject to the provisions set forth in § 3-312 of the Village Law.
Section three adds a new subdivision to § 15-108 of the Election Law to require any candidates for village elective office establish residency by the time they file nominating or designating petitions.
Section four adds a new section to Article 15 of the Election Law to provide a practical format for villages using hand-counted paper ballots, as opposed to lever or scanning machines.
Section five adds a new subdivision to § 15-108 of the Election Law, to specify that for village elections, any papers required to be filed with the village election officer must be delivered on or before 5 PM on the last day to file.
Section six sets the enacting date.
Villages running their own elections face unique challenges. The provisions in this bill are meant to address issues experienced by village election officers and candidates. Specifically:
There has been confusion as to how many signatures are required for independent nominating petitions in villages with less than a thousand residents. The language provided in this bill would clarify a common misconception that the number required is 5% of those that actually voted in the previous village election. Statements from the state Board of Election and other statutory provisions indicate that the
number of signatures required is actually 5% of registered voters at the last election.
The law is silent as to what happens when someone elected to office declines the position. This bill would provide villages with a practical procedure to address declinations of office.
Currently, the law allows candidates for village office to establish residency by Election Day. However, unintended vacancies in office have occurred when candidates have failed to establish proper residency. Requiring candidates for village office to establish residency by the date of nomination, as opposed to the date of the election, will deter such vacancies.
Currently, New York's election law only addresses the format of paper ballots that are to be used by scanner voting machines and does not provide for any other form of paper ballot. Consequently, villages that are conducting elections by hand count must either use paper ballots in a format that complies with state law but is unsuitable for the hand counting process, or use paper ballots in a format that work for hand counted elections, but do not comply with state law. This legislation will correct this oversight.
Under the Election Law, election paperwork is deemed to have been timely filed so long as it is postmarked before midnight of the last date to file a petition. This is problematic because it deters individuals from lawfully examining and challenging designating petitions and nominating petition, since prospective challengers must file their challenges not later than one day after the last day to file petitions with the village clerk. Thus, if a candidate postmarks his petition on the last day, and it is received by the clerk the next day, or even later, the deadline for someone to challenge that petition has passed. This legislation will address the issue by requiring candidates to file papers on or before the due date.
This act shall take effect immediately.
STATE OF NEW YORK ________________________________________________________________________ 899--A 2013-2014 Regular Sessions IN SENATE (PREFILED) January 9, 2013 ___________Introduced by Sen. MARTINS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Elections -- recommitted to the Committee on Elections in accordance with Senate Rule 6, sec. 8 -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee AN ACT to amend the election law, in relation to clarifying the number of signatures required on an independent nominating petition in a municipality with less than a thousand residents, declination of office and filling vacancies, establishing residency at the time of nomination in village elections, paper ballots counted by hand in village elections and eliminating the ability of a candidate to timely file via mailing with postmark before midnight of the last date to file a petition THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM- BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Subdivision 6 of section 15-108 of the election law is amended to read as follows: 6. An independent nominating petition for a village office must be signed by at least one hundred voters in villages containing a popu- lation of five thousand or more; by at least seventy-five voters in villages containing a population of three thousand and less than five thousand; and by at least fifty voters in villages containing a popu- lation of one thousand and less than three thousand; and in villages containing a population of less than one thousand by voters numbering at least five per centum of the number of
[voters]THOSE PERSONS REGISTERED TO VOTE at the last regular village election. For the purposes of this section, the population of a village shall be determined by the last federal decennial or local special population census federally super- vised pursuant to section twenty of the general municipal law.EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets [ ] is old law to be omitted. LBD03537-02-4 S. 899--A 2
S 2. The opening paragraph of section 15-128 of the election law is designated subdivision 1 and a new subdivision 2 is added to read as follows: 2. A PERSON ELECTED MAY DECLINE THE OFFICE TO WHICH HE OR SHE WAS ELECTED BY NOTIFYING THE VILLAGE CLERK IN WRITING. THE FILING OF A WRIT- TEN DECLINATION WITH THE VILLAGE CLERK CREATES A VACANCY IN THE OFFICE EFFECTIVE AT THE START OF THE OFFICIAL YEAR FOLLOWING THE ELECTION. THE VACANCY SHALL BE FILLED AFTER THE START OF THE OFFICIAL YEAR BY THE MAYOR, EXCEPT THAT A VACANCY IN THE OFFICE OF MAYOR SHALL BE FILLED BY THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, IN THE SAME MANNER AND FOR THE PERIODS OF TIME SET FORTH IN SECTION 3-312 OF THE VILLAGE LAW. S 3. Section 15-108 of the election law is amended by adding a new subdivision 11 to read as follows: 11. AN INDIVIDUAL RUNNING FOR ELECTED OFFICE MUST BE A RESIDENT OF THE VILLAGE BY THE LAST DAY TO FILE A CERTIFICATE OF PARTY NOMINATION IF SUCH INDIVIDUAL IS NOMINATED AT A PARTY PRIMARY OR CAUCUS, NOT LATER THAN FORTY-SEVEN DAYS PRIOR TO THE VILLAGE ELECTION PURSUANT TO PARA- GRAPH A OF SUBDIVISION SEVEN OF THIS SECTION, OR BY THE LAST DAY TO FILE AN INDEPENDENT NOMINATING PETITION IF SUCH INDIVIDUAL IS NOMINATED BY THE FILING OF AN INDEPENDENT NOMINATING PETITION, NOT LATER THAN THIR- TY-FIVE DAYS PRIOR TO THE VILLAGE ELECTION PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH A OF SUBDIVISION EIGHT OF THIS SECTION. S 4. The election law is amended by adding a new section 15-115 to read as follows: S 15-115. PAPER BALLOTS COUNTED BY HAND IN VILLAGE ELECTIONS. 1. FOR VILLAGES CONDUCTING AN ELECTION WHERE PAPER BALLOTS ARE TO BE COUNTED BY HAND, THE FORMAT OF THE BALLOTS SHALL CONFORM TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION. THIS SECTION SHALL NOT APPLY TO ELECTIONS WHERE SCANNER MACHINES ARE USED. 2. PAPER BALLOTS SHALL BE PRINTED ON PAPER OF A QUALITY, SIZE, COLOR, AND WEIGHT THAT HAD BEEN APPROVED BY THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTIONS PRIOR TO THE SEVENTH DAY OF JULY, TWO THOUSAND FOURTEEN. 3. ALL PAPER BALLOTS OF THE SAME KIND FOR THE SAME POLLING PLACE SHALL BE IDENTICAL. A DIFFERENT, BUT IN EACH CASE UNIFORM STYLE AND SIZE OF TYPE, SHALL BE USED FOR PRINTING THE NAMES OF CANDIDATES, THE TITLES OF OFFICES, POLITICAL DESIGNATIONS, AND THE READING FORM OF ALL QUESTIONS SUBMITTED. THE NAMES OF CANDIDATES SHALL BE PRINTED IN CAPITAL LETTERS IN BLACK-FACED TYPE. 4. EACH BALLOT SHALL BE PRINTED ON THE SAME SHEET WITH A STUB WHICH SHALL BE SEPARATED THEREFROM BY A HORIZONTAL LINE OF PERFORATIONS EXTENDING ACROSS THE ENTIRE WIDTH OF THE BALLOT. ON THE FACE OF THE STUB SHALL BE PRINTED THE INSTRUCTIONS TO THE VOTER. ON THE BACK OF THE STUB IMMEDIATELY ABOVE THE CENTER OF THE INDORSEMENT ON THE BACK OF THE BALLOT, SHALL BE PRINTED "NO. ......" THE BLANK TO BE FILLED WITH CONSECUTIVE NUMBER OF BALLOTS BEGINNING WITH "NO. 1", AND INCREASING IN REGULAR NUMERICAL ORDER. 5. ON THE BACK OF THE BALLOT, BELOW THE LINE OF PERFORATIONS, JUST TO THE RIGHT OF CENTER, AND OUTSIDE WHEN THE BALLOT IS FOLDED, AND ON THE FRONT OF THE BALLOT, DIRECTLY BELOW THE PERFORATED LINE, SHALL BE PRINT- ED THE FOLLOWING INDORSEMENT, THE BLANKS PROPERLY FILLED IN: "OFFICIAL BALLOT FOR VILLAGE OFFICERS. (DATE OF ELECTION.) (FACSIMILE OF THE SIGNATURE OF OFFICER OR OFFICERS PROVIDING THE BALLOT.)" 6. ON THE STUB AT THE TOP OF THE BALLOT OR ON THE EDGE OF SUCH BALLOT SHALL BE PRINTED IN HEAVY BLACK TYPE THE FOLLOWING INSTRUCTIONS:S. 899--A 3
"INSTRUCTIONS (1) MARK ONLY WITH A PEN HAVING BLUE OR BLACK INK OR WITH A PENCIL HAVING BLACK LEAD. (2) TO VOTE FOR A CANDIDATE WHOSE NAME IS PRINTED ON THIS BALLOT MAKE A SINGLE CROSS X MARK OR A CHECK V MARK IN ONE OF THE SQUARES TO THE RIGHT OF AN EMBLEM OPPOSITE HIS OR HER NAME. (3) TO VOTE FOR A PERSON WHOSE NAME IS NOT PRINTED ON THIS BALLOT WRITE OR STAMP HIS OR HER NAME ON A BLANK LINE UNDER THE NAMES OF THE CANDI- DATES FOR THAT OFFICE. (4) TO VOTE YES OR NO ON A PROPOSAL MAKE A SINGLE X OR V MARK IN THE SQUARE OPPOSITE YOUR VOTE. (5) ANY OTHER MARK OR WRITING, OR ANY ERASURE MADE ON THIS BALLOT OUTSIDE THE VOTING SQUARES OR BLANK SPACES PROVIDED FOR VOTING WILL VOID THIS ENTIRE BALLOT. (6) DO NOT OVERVOTE. IF YOU SELECT A GREATER NUMBER OF CANDIDATES THAN THERE ARE VACANCIES TO BE FILLED, YOUR BALLOT WILL BE VOID FOR THAT PUBLIC OFFICE OR PARTY POSITION. (7) IF YOU TEAR, OR DEFACE, OR WRONGLY MARK THIS BALLOT, RETURN IT AND OBTAIN ANOTHER. DO NOT ATTEMPT TO CORRECT MISTAKES ON THE BALLOT BY MAKING ERASURES OR CROSS OUTS. ERASURES OR CROSS OUTS MAY INVALIDATE ALL OR PART OF YOUR BALLOT. PRIOR TO SUBMITTING YOUR BALLOT, IF YOU MAKE A MISTAKE IN COMPLETING THE BALLOT OR WISH TO CHANGE YOUR BALLOT CHOICES, YOU MAY OBTAIN AND COMPLETE A NEW BALLOT. YOU HAVE A RIGHT TO A REPLACE- MENT BALLOT UPON RETURN OF THE ORIGINAL BALLOT." 7. EACH SUCH BALLOT SHALL BE PRINTED IN SECTIONS IN WHICH THE CANDI- DATES' NAMES, EMBLEMS AND POLITICAL DESIGNATIONS, THE BALLOT PROPOSALS AND OTHER REQUISITE MATTER SHALL EACH BE BOXED IN BY HEAVY BLACK LINES. ON THE BALLOT SHALL BE VOTING SQUARES IN WHICH VOTERS MAY MAKE THEIR VOTING MARKS. ALL VOTING SQUARES SHALL BE BOUNDED BY HEAVY BLACK LINES, THE PERPENDICULAR LINES TO BE NOT LESS THAN ONE-SIXTEENTH OF AN INCH WIDE. THE VOTING SQUARES AND THE SPACES OCCUPIED BY THE EMBLEM SHALL HAVE A DEPTH AND WIDTH OF FIVE-SIXTEENTHS OF AN INCH. NO VOTING SQUARES SHALL BE PROVIDED IN FRONT OF THE BLANK SPACES PROVIDED FOR A VOTER TO WRITE IN A NAME. 8. THE SPACE FOR THE TITLE OF AN OFFICE SHALL BE THREE-EIGHTHS OF AN INCH, AND THE NAME OF A CANDIDATE OR FOR WRITING IN A NAME, ONE-FOURTH OF AN INCH, IN DEPTH. AT THE LEFT OF THE NAME OF EACH DESIGNATED CANDI- DATE SHALL BE AN ENCLOSED VOTING SPACE, THREE-EIGHTHS OF AN INCH IN WIDTH AND APPROXIMATELY ONE-FOURTH OF AN INCH IN DEPTH, BOUNDED ABOVE, BELOW AND TO THE RIGHT BY BLACK LINES, HEAVIER THAN THOSE WHICH SEPARATE THE SPACES CONTAINING THE NAMES OF CANDIDATES. TO THE LEFT OF VOTING SPACES WHICH DO NOT ADJOIN A VERTICAL LINE DIVIDING TWO PARTS, THERE SHALL BE A HEAVY BLACK VERTICAL LINE APPROXIMATELY ONE-EIGHTH OF AN INCH IN WIDTH. NO VOTING SPACE SHALL BE PROVIDED IN THE SPACE FOR WRITING IN NAMES. IN SUCH CASE, THE SPACE CORRESPONDING TO A VOTING SPACE SHALL BE ALL BLACK. 9. BELOW THE NAMES OF THE CANDIDATES FOR EACH OFFICE OR POSITION THERE SHALL BE PRINTED AS MANY BLANK SPACES, FOR WRITING IN NAMES OF PERSONS FOR WHOM THE VOTER DESIRES TO VOTE, AS THERE ARE PERSONS TO BE NOMINATED OR ELECTED. 10. IN CASE THE SECTIONS SHALL BE SO NUMEROUS AS TO MAKE THE BALLOT UNWIELDY IF THEY ARE PRINTED IN ONE COLUMN, THEY MAY BE PRINTED IN AS MANY COLUMNS AS SHALL BE NECESSARY, AND IN THAT CASE, IN ORDER TO PRODUCE A RECTANGULAR BALLOT, BLANK SECTIONS MAY BE USED. 11. THE NAMES OF PARTIES OR INDEPENDENT BODIES WHICH CONTAIN MORE THAN FIFTEEN LETTERS MAY, WHENEVER LIMITATIONS OF SPACE SO REQUIRE, BE PRINT-S. 899--A 4
ED ON THE BALLOT IN AN ABBREVIATED FORM. IN PRINTING THE NAMES OF CANDI- DATES WHOSE FULL NAMES CONTAIN MORE THAN FIFTEEN LETTERS, ONLY THE SURNAME MUST BE PRINTED IN FULL. THE OFFICER OR BOARD CHARGED WITH THE DUTY OF PREPARING THE BALLOTS SHALL REQUEST EACH SUCH CANDIDATE TO INDI- CATE, IN WRITING, THE SHORTENED FORM IN WHICH, SUBJECT TO THIS RESTRICTION, HIS NAME SHALL BE PRINTED. IF NO SUCH INDICATION IS RECEIVED FROM SUCH CANDIDATE WITHIN THE TIME SPECIFIED IN THE REQUEST, SUCH OFFICER OR BOARD SHALL MAKE THE NECESSARY DETERMINATION. NO EMBLEM SHALL OCCUPY A SPACE LONGER IN ANY DIRECTION THAN THE VOTING SQUARE TO WHICH IT RELATES. S 5. Section 15-108 of the election law is amended by adding a new subdivision 12 to read as follows: 12. NOTWITHSTANDING THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 1-106 OF THIS CHAPTER, ALL PAPERS REQUIRED TO BE FILED PURSUANT TO THIS ARTICLE WHICH ARE DELIVERED IN PERSON OR SENT BY MAIL TO THE VILLAGE ELECTION OFFICER AS DEFINED IN SECTION 15-124 OF THIS ARTICLE SHALL BE DEEMED TIMELY FILED WHEN RECEIVED BY THE VILLAGE ELECTION OFFICER ON OR BEFORE FIVE P.M. ON THE LAST DAY TO FILE ANY SUCH PAPERS. FAILURE OF THE POST OFFICE OR ANY OTHER PERSON OR ENTITY TO DELIVER SUCH PAPERS ON OR BEFORE FIVE P.M. ON THE LAST DAY TO FILE SHALL BE A FATAL DEFECT. S 6. This act shall take effect immediately.